Paper 03 · 8 min read · April 28, 2026

The five A+ setups that pay.

Most setups don't pay. Five do. The ones the desk takes at full size, what they win, what they cost, and how often they show up.

VWAP + W

RR 4.80

VWAP + Horiz

RR 4.22

VWAP + VolSurge

RR 4.00

VWAP + Bull Flag

173 fires / 7yr

Setups don't pay. Confluence does.

The most important finding in the entire futures research file is that no single detector pays well on its own. A solo VWAP-reclaim is roughly an even-money fire. A solo bull flag is a tossup. A solo volume surge is noise. The setups that win at tradeable RR are setups where two or more detectors fire on the same minute.

These are the five combinations that the seven-year dataset isolates as A+: the handful that, when you only take them, give you the headline 64% win rate and the 1.93 profit factor.

The five A+ setups

Star — VWAP + W

58% WR / RR 4.80

~0.32 fires/day

VW + Horizontal

63% WR / RR 4.22

~0.07 fires/day

VW + Volume Surge

61% WR / RR 4.00

Tightest expectancy

VW + Bull Flag

68% WR / RR 3.38

The workhorse

The fifth tag is T1 — any minute on which four or more of the eight detectors fire simultaneously, regardless of which four. It's rare (roughly 0.06 fires per day) but the historical RR is ~4.7 — when the entire stack lines up, you take it.

The five A+ setups — frequency × risk:reward — Each setup plotted by frequency (x) and historical RR (y). Bubble size scales with fires/year, color shades darker green at higher win rates. The Star (VWAP+W) sits in the upper-right — rare, but the highest RR per fire. The Workhorse (VWAP+Bull Flag) sits in the lower-right — most frequent of the named combos, lower RR, but biggest dollar contributor because it shows up most often. T1 stack and Horizontal cluster in the upper-left: very rare, very high RR per fire.

The five setups, with examples

Each setup below is followed by a real example from the seven-year dataset — a clean session that fired the setup and held the long thesis through 12:30 ET. Charts are MNQ 1-minute bars, 9:30–13:00 ET, with session VWAP overlaid. The arrow points to the trigger bar.

1. VWAP + W — the Star (highest RR)

The highest-RR setup we've measured. ~0.32 fires per day, 58% win rate, RR 4.80. The pattern: a clean W on price after a reclaim of VWAP, with the right leg of the W breaking back above the neckline. The asymmetry is what makes the RR — the stop sits below the right-leg low, the target sits well above the W's neckline, and the move that follows is usually the day's main impulse.

Frequency: ~0.32 fires/day · Win rate: 58% · Historical RR: 4.80

MNQ VWAP + W — Nov 14, 2025 — November 14, 2025. VWAP + W trigger at 10:20 ET — open low at 24640, bounce to 24960, right-leg low at 24870, neckline break fires the long. ~233 MNQ points favorable in the next 30 minutes; price never re-tests below the W's right leg; close at 12:30 ET sits 296 points above entry. The textbook Star entry.

2. VWAP + Horizontal channel breakout

When price has bounded between two horizontal levels above VWAP for at least 15 bars, the breakout of the upper band with VWAP still in support is a 63% / RR 4.22 setup. Rare — about 0.07 fires per day — but extremely clean when it shows up. The pre- breakout consolidation is a coiled spring; the breakout fires the long.

Frequency: ~0.07 fires/day · Win rate: 63% · Historical RR: 4.22

MNQ VWAP + Horizontal channel — Sep 28, 2023 — September 28, 2023. VWAP + Horizontal trigger at 11:20 ET — price oscillates between 14760 support and 14790 resistance for 50 minutes with VWAP ramping below the floor. Breakout above 14790 fires the long. ~113 MNQ points favorable in 30 minutes; close at 12:30 ET sits 162 points above entry.

3. VWAP + Volume Surge

A VWAP-reclaim minute on which the most recent bar's volume is at least 4× the rolling baseline. 61% WR, RR 4.00. It's the lowest of the four named combos but it has the tightest stop-to-target ratio and the most evenly distributed win distribution — fewer outsized wins, fewer outsized losses, smoother equity curve.

Frequency: ~0.20 fires/day · Win rate: 61% · Historical RR: 4.00

MNQ VWAP + Volume Surge — Aug 13, 2019 — August 13, 2019. VWAP + Volume Surge trigger at 09:31 ET — first RTH bar prints with volume more than 4× baseline (the trade-talk rally). Open at 7556 immediately ramps. ~218 MNQ points favorable in 30 minutes with only 0.8 points of adverse; close at 12:30 ET sits 183 points above entry.

4. VWAP + Bull Flag — the workhorse

One hundred and seventy three fires across seven years. 68% win rate. RR 3.38. It's not the highest expected value per fire — that's the W-pattern combo — but it's the single biggest dollar contributor to the strategy because it shows up most often. Visually: price has come back through VWAP from below, then spent a few minutes consolidating in a tight range with the prior swing. That tight consolidation is the bull flag. The minute it breaks the upper edge with the VWAP still under it is the fire.

Frequency: 173 fires / 7 years · Win rate: 68% · Historical RR: 3.38

If you only ever traded VWAP+BF, you'd capture roughly 43% of the entire strategy's historical P&L. It's the load-bearing setup.

MNQ VWAP + Bull Flag — Oct 13, 2022 — October 13, 2022 — the historic CPI rally. Price grinds above VWAP through the morning, consolidates in a tight 11:00–11:12 pennant just above 10760, breaks out at 11:13 ET. ~330 MNQ points favorable in 30 minutes; close at 12:30 ET sits 151 points above entry; the day prints to 11100 by 11:50 ET. The canonical workhorse.

5. T1 stack — full-stack alignment

Any minute on which four or more of the eight detectors fire simultaneously, regardless of which four. It's the rarest setup in the list — roughly 0.06 fires per day — but the historical RR is ~4.7. When the entire stack lines up, you take it. Most T1 fires occur in the first 30 minutes, but the example below is a midday trigger to show the convergence isn't gated to the open.

Frequency: ~0.06 fires/day · Win rate: 64% · Historical RR: 4.7

MNQ T1 stack — Mar 5, 2025 — March 5, 2025. T1 stack trigger at 12:17 ET — VWAP-reclaim, W-pattern, and horizontal-channel detectors all fire on the same minute as the morning chop bottoms out at 20220 around 11:45 ET. ~107 MNQ points favorable in 30 minutes; close at 12:30 sits 63 points above entry; the afternoon rally takes price to 20570. Convergence as decisive signal.

How the desk reads them

We don't ask the trader to memorize five separate playbooks. The TradingView indicator we built for this strategy renders each combo as a tagged label on the bar where it fires. Star icon for VWAP+W, gold “A+” for the T1 four-stack, teal labels for the other three.

The decision is binary: marker on the bar, bias-aligned, before 12:30, not in the chop minute, not in cooldown — fire. No marker — pass. The rules collapse the framework into an action.

What you'll see in the next paper is the inverse: the setups the indicator doesn't mark, and why ignoring them is the difference between a 64% win rate and a 51%.

Futures waitlist

We're not running futures live yet. When we do, you'll be the first to know.

The research above is what we measure before we run a single dollar of subscriber money. Drop your email if you want first access when MNQ goes live on the desk.

Email only used for futures launch notifications. Unsubscribe any time.