The desk,
in full.

01 — The tax math is real

A high-turnover options strategy run inside a taxable brokerage produces a short-term capital gain on every winning trade in the year it closes. The desk closes north of two hundred trades a year. Each one is taxed at ordinary-income rates, and the bill is owed in April whether you withdrew the money or not. The tax line item compounds against the strategy.

02 — The wrapper matters more for us

A passive index strategy doesn't care much about wrapper choice — turnover is near zero. A high-turnover options strategy is the worst-case profile in a taxable account, and the best-case profile in a Roth. The same fills, in the same broker, in two different wrappers, produce dramatically different lifetime outcomes. The wrapper choice matters more for us than for almost anyone.

03 — The cash side funds the Roth side

The desk runs cash today by design. The plan: let market gains fund the annual Roth contribution, so the wrapper gets paid for out of the strategy itself — not from a paycheck. If you're starting in cash too — MAGI phase-out, you prefer the flexibility, you already maxxed Roth elsewhere — running the strategy in a regular cash brokerage is fully supported. You eat the tax line item until the wrapper opens up. Both wrappers are first-class on the desk.